The Springbok rugby team is currently hampered by their lack of an openside flanker of world-class quality like Richie McCaw.
Stephen Nell
This was what former All Black loose forward Zinzan Brooke said this week when he was asked about the Boks’ struggling form.
“There is no-one like Richie McCaw in South Africa’s loose trio. Australia has David Pocock and England has Lewis Moody. South Africa doesn’t have a top openside flanker who can make his mark in contact situations on tour,” Brooke said to Sport24 at the announcement of Land Rover as sponsor for the World Cup tournaments in 2011 and 2015.
“Pocock offers the Aussies a good counterpart for McCaw. South Africa has the players but they aren’t on tour.”
Pretender to the crown Heinrich Brüssow is injured, while the Bok selectors decided not to pick Francois Louw.
Schalk Burger is also injured, and has for some time now ceased to play exclusively as a ball fetcher.
The fetcher job has been given to Deon Stegmann, and on Saturday at Twickenham he will get a chance against England to prove that Brooke’s statement is debatable.
In the Test against Scotland, Stegmann was reprimanded by Steve Walsh in Cardiff on numerous occasions, a fact that has led Brooke to wonder about the treatment that South Africa received during the match.
Although the Boks were clearly frustrated by Dickinson, they have decided not to take the referee on in public. Brooke, however, didn’t hold back.
“It bothers me when I look at the way in which the match was handled. Juan Smith was punished (for being off his feet) when he was clearly in the right position,” said Brooke.
“It is Victor Matfield’s right to question decisions on the field and there has to be a problem if he does it six or seven times within a few minutes.”
“It will be a very physical game (against England) and I won’t hazard a prediction. South Africa is clearly with its back against the wall…South Africans don’t like losing and the team now has to react in a positive way.”
“There are a few players who aren’t playing well, but South Africa’s defeats in the Tri-Nations series were not bad, at least.”
“If you lose, the way in which it happens is important. England recently lost against New Zealand but took a lot from the match because in the last 20 minutes of the game they played better than the All Blacks.”
Brooke isn’t worried that the All Blacks appear to be peaking a year before the World Cup tournament. “I believe New Zealand are the favourites.”
Do we need a McCaw or a Henry?
need a henry more than a mc aw we have a brussow who will be fit come wc time
Zinnie looks at a match like I do… from the perspective of which position you played…
Whilst I agree with Brooke, I must add that the Bokke problems are NOT LIMITED to openside fetcher, it goes much deeper, I’m afraid and our most hindersome shortcomings are in backline play and not valueing possession.
n goeie afrigter sal ook help.ek hoop n die pending nederlaag more en teen die barbarians fire hulle de villiers.hy sal nooit bedank nie en weet hy het met sy gat in die botter geval met die bok afrigterpos..maar wat is die kanse dat hy gefire sal word?zero.
4@ Piet visagie:
Jy’s ‘n week te vroeg, ons speel eers more teen die Bleekbene (Ingeland)… volgende week teen die BaaBaas.
ek probeer vergeet van more.eish,ek sal maar die poms game kyk al weet mens wat om te verwag.skop,skop, senters wat bo oor almal probeer hardloop,swak lynstane en vrot tackels.dit meester game plan van die 3 maaitjies.
For me the only real great out and out fetcher we have is Brussow. The only fetcher I would select too. Do we really need a fetcher these days? Will have to wait and see once Brussow is back, cause Stegmann is not doing it that is for sure.
7@ Puma:
Yes, Brussow is the only true fetcher in the mould I like, but one cannot probably blame Stegmann for the Bokke problems… after all our forwards were our outstanding performers against Ireland and Wales and to a lessor extent against the Scots…. the backline just cannot seem to attack or defend man…
Oh… and do we need a true fetcher…. for sure we do, no doubt in my mind, none at all… go see what Zinzan Brooke said on another Article. Specially around slowing opposition ball down to make their attacks slow and predictable with defences properly set.
Users Online
Total 61 users including 0 member, 61 guests, 0 bot online
Most users ever online were 3735, on 31 August 2022 @ 6:23 pm
No Counter as from 31 October 2009: 39,485,349 Page Impressions
_