Archie Henderson: So the Tri-Nations wasn’t as bad as we thought. We might have lost all but one of the six matches against our old enemies and conceded the most tries, but – hell’s bells! – we made a lot of money going about it.

“For every point we conceded against the All Blacks, we made a packet”

The cash rolled in despite some poor performances on the field and yet another gaffe by the coach about supporting a murder suspect “100%”.

Peter de Villiers might have made us cringe and the Boks made us cry, but now for the good news.

A bunch of clever number-crunchers at a place called the Centre for International Business of Sport at Coventry University in England, commissioned by MasterCard, have done the sums and, basically, for every point we conceded against the All Blacks and the Wallabies and for every try we gave away, we made a packet.

When I say “we”, I mean the cities where the matches were played. All the sums have been done in US dollars, but it looks much more impressive in rands, so the total contribution of the Tri-Nations to the “sport and leisure economies” of the host cities came to R1.3-billion.

South Africa on its own made R268-million from the three games here, with Joburg leading the way on R141-million for the FNB stadium Test against the All Blacks.

Pretoria was less than half that at R66-million and Bloemfontein R61.8-million of which a large percentage must have been the bar takings at the Mystic Boer, although the study does not go there.

Oddly, the two Test venues where the Boks were beaten – Johannesburg and Bloem – far outstrip the single win at Loftus: R202.5-million to R66-million. So losing doesn’t appear to affect spending habits. Is this what the economists mean by “deficit spending”?

As impressive as this sounds, it is dwarfed by the Six Nations, which brought in R4.55-billion.

In two years’ time, when the Pumas join the Tri-Nations, the figure is expected to climb to R1.5-billion because, the study says, rugby is growing faster in Argentina than in any of the current member countries.

Reasons for the latest growth is put down to broadcasting and attendance, which is up 50000 to 450000. Apparently this is marginally higher, on average, than the World Cup. The highest single attendance figure was the 94013 at FNB stadium against the All Blacks. It was the highest gate for a South African rugby match in more than 50 years, eclipsing that epic against the British Lions of 1955 at Ellis Park.

What the study doesn’t say, possibly because it has little bearing on the economics of the game, is that there is still a lot wrong with our game. Our defence has gone to pieces, the skipper looks dead on his feet and the coach can’t keep his feet out of his mouth.

It’s fascinating to note the contrast with, say, Australia. One of its leading sportswomen lost all sense of civility with a “suck on that faggots” twitter.

Stephanie Rice was quickly slapped down, losing a Jaguar sponsorship and being forced to make a tearful apology.

Whether it was done because the said faggots objected to being compared with the Springboks is unknown, but it was very different from allowing De Villiers to get off scot-free with his own silliness.

De Villiers is to rugby what Julius Malema is to the ANC, but rugby does not have a Jeremy Cronin, brave enough to stand up to such absurdities.

For all the money that rugby has made this season, a slapdown of Div would have been priceless.

8 Responses to Tri-Nations not a total loss

  • 1

    “So losing doesn’t appear to affect spending habits. Is this what the economists mean by “deficit spending”?

    Depends whether the losing Cities where driven to alcohol , and see guys Pretoria is not the Drinking Capital of South Africa.

  • 2

    So the economy awards poor performance.

    Fantastic.

  • 3

    As soon as Regan Hoskins reads this article the administration, coaches and players will all recieve increases.

    Rewarding poor performance once again.

    Fantastic

  • 4

    Knowing a thing or two about Coventry (having been born there), I am forced to ask “can we trust these figures?”

    Coventry University? Hmmmm

  • 5

    Hold On…Coventry University is really a technikon. Great for hairdressing and golf course upkeep but its not Oxford !

    Scrumdown, I’m sure these figures are for SWC and not Tri Nations. R61 Miilion, R66 Million, R202 Million are not the sort of figures for individual tri nations games at all.

    There is no way a local fan (which 3N fans are) will be spending that sort of money on a dop, tjop and skrop weekend in Bloem, JHB or Pretoria. But it is the sort of money an international soccer fan would spend on hotels and tickets over a week or two in a host city.
    Hell, not even a massive Twickers weekend would cost anywhere near that.

    There is nothing on the universities website about 3N rugby but they do talk about SWC and its impact so I think thats where this originated.

    Sorry you are from Cov, as they say someone has to come from there. Its got a fancy IKEA and an icerink if that makes you feel better.

  • 6

    We are missing the point of the article though, the revenues should have been far higher if we won, I was at the FNB stadium as well as Loftus and the crowd attendance was terrible considering it was Matfields 100th test match. But then it is expected when you have to pay R 495 for cheap seats, why not sell some seats for R 150 and fill up the bloddy stadium, it is totally unacceptable if a stadium is not full when the Boks play.

  • 7

    @ Mielie Pap Mike:
    MPM

    Yeah it used to be a Polytechnic or some such thing.

    As for the ice rink, the local team won the UK champ’s recently (in 2008 I think), and the Speedway team (Coventry Bees) are currently the Elite League champ’s and are in the final again over the next 2 weeks against Poole.

    Pity the Rugby team has sunk so low.

    Never embraced professionalism in time (IMO) and are still struggling to regain past glories.

    Coventry of the 1970’s were a really good Rugby club.

  • 8

    @ Mielie Pap Mike:
    By the way, Kempton Park, where I now live also has an ice-rink, but that don’t make it great either. There isn’t a fancy IKEA though!

    I must say Cov’s once famous Ring Road looks (and operates) rather tired nowadays!

Users Online

Total 28 users including 0 member, 28 guests, 0 bot online

Most users ever online were 3735, on 31 August 2022 @ 6:23 pm