Ask-Ads Left

Australian lock Rob Simmons had his ban for a dangerous tip-tackle during the Wallabies defeat by France this month cut from eight weeks to five weeks, following an International Rugby Board appeal hearing in Bristol, south-west England.


His reduced suspension means Simmons will still be banned from the concluding match of the Wallabies’ European tour, against Wales in Cardiff on Saturday, with the second row having already missed the wins over England and Italy.

On as a replacement, Simmons was cited by South African match official Freek Burger for his challenge on Yannick Nyanga midway through the second half of Australia’s tour-opening 33-6 loss to France in Paris on November 10.

During the course of the match, Welsh referee Nigel Owens was heard apologising for the failure to issue a red card for the challenge on Nyanga due to a collective inability to identify tackler Simmons.

The original disciplinary hearing determined 23-year-old Simmons had been guilty of an offence at the “high end entry point” of seriousness.

An appeal hearing chaired by lawyer Chris Quinlan of England, which started on Tuesday but did not publish its verdict until the early hours of Wednesday morning, found Simmons, a veteran of 23 Tests, had committed the act of foul play and so dismissed the player’s appeal on that point.

But a statement issued by the Six Nations Committee, which oversees disciplinary matters on behalf of the IRB during the European year-end internationals, added the appeal committee “had found that the player’s offending had merited a mid-range entry point, rather than the top end entry point that the judicial officer had originally found”.

It added: “After applying aggravating and mitigating factors, the appeal committee imposed a reduced sanction of five weeks.

“Therefore the player will be free to play from February 4, 2013.”

As was the case with the original ban, the reduced punishment takes account of the close season inactivity after the end of the Wallaby tour when Williams and his Wallaby team-mates are not scheduled to play.

One Response to Rob Simmons’ “Sentence” reduced to 5 weeks on appeal

  • 1

    Just putting this here as it is about the Aussies.

    How does the rankings work? See Oz are hoping to leap frog the Boks into 2nd this weekend by beating Wales.

    This will be them having played 2 more games than us? Surely it should be worked out on percentage rather than games then? Otherwise these rankings are a farce for sure.

    This from rugby365. Only copied a part of it that mattered.


    Wallabies look to leapfrog Boks

    Wed, 28 Nov 2012 12:44

    It would be huge

    Australia would love to conquer Wales on Saturday and finish the year as they started – ranked second in the world behind the All Blacks, according to playmaker Berrick Barnes.


Bam Advert