South African Super Rugby Franchises







The Sharks



Click on any of the pictures to go to that franchise

As the Heineken Cup season gets under way, a series of controversial decisions by match officials in opening matches, has led to the International Rugby Board’s decision trial the wider use of television match officials to help get more accurate opinions on red card offences and crucial forward passes, among other things.


The trial will be operated over two competitions, one northern and one southern hemisphere, and the Premiership will be the chosen host next season. The aim is to prevent miscarriages of justice such as Manu Tuilagi’s yellow card for punching Chris Ashton last season.

In order to process the natural flow of the game, two possible options are being suggested, to  leave the decision to refer a decision entirely to the referee, or to offer each captain one referral per game.

The small margins in the scores in top rugby clashes make it crucial for officials to get pivotal decisions right. For instance, had Bath been beaten by Montpellier and been out of Europe as a result, the decision to award the second-half try would have caused a monumental row.

Bath have seen six of their matches already this season go down to the final play, while if Northampton felt they had been wronged during the final phases at Thomond  Park, under the new scheme, Dylan Hartley could have asked for the specific piece of video to be checked.

Although there are naturally concerns as to the detail, coaches are believed to be widely in favour of a move which will increase accuracy in the emerging professional game.

3 Responses to International Rugby Board to trial wider use of video replays

  • 1


    SA has trialled it in Varsity Cup already and it worked like a charm!

    I’m all for getting on field decisions right!

    Go for it!

  • 2

    Was it in PE that the TMO asked the ref if he could view further evidence to adjudicate if the try could be awarded? SA vs NZ. Try was disalllowed because of an earlier infringement. That caused a huge outcry, and even dear old Paddy entered into the fray, because the TMO exceeded the set protocals, yet in the end the decision was a correct one.

  • 3

    @ Lion4ever:
    Paddy and his protocols.

    Would they have been able to have a second look at the NZ winning penalty in the WC final if the French had asked for it?

    Could have set the cat amongst the pigeons.


Rugby-Talk TRC 2014

Pool Name: Rugby-Talk TRC 2014
Pool Code: shutwins

Rule: You HAVE TO BE REGISTERED (as a Subscriber here on www.rugby-talk.com) to be eligible for acceptance in the Rugby-Talk pools on SuperBru.

The Pool is now OPEN for Applications.

Bam Advert

Bornman Graphic